Below is a sample of an IPO that received our highest
rating. This report was actually written for our subscribers on
10/16/2005:
CBOT Holdings
BOT IPO $50-$52 3.2 million shares Underwriter(s) CS First
Boston, JP Morgan, Citigroup Proposed trade date 10/19.
One of the
world's largest derivative exchanges, offering futures and
options on futures.
CBOT Holdings
which is the operator of the number 2 futures exchange, and a key
trading floor for agricultural commodities is set to open for
trade on Wednesday. CBOT has been a long awaited IPO. This is
especially since the spectacular performance of The Chicago
Mercantile Exchange CME (actually went Public at $35.00 in
12/02)… current closing quote $317.20 which is a 52 week
increase of 85.33 percent or 800 % since its debut. CBOT
originally filed at a price range of $33-$36.
Despite the
extremely large demand for this offering it is not a large deal.
This IPO is estimated, if priced at the high end, to bring in
approximately 156 million. On average this year IPO's included
11.5 million shares and brought in on average 174.5 million.
Price to book ratio is a ratio that is often used in comparing
the value of one similar company versus another. The lower the
value the better. In the case of CBOT the price to book is 5.4.
If we take that number and compare it to Chicago Mercantile
Exchange CME it is 11.7, the Nasdaq Stock Market NDAQ 14.1 and
11.9 at online brokerage OptionsXpress OXPS.
The amount of
shares being offered by CBOT is only 6.1 percent of the
outstanding shares. Therefore, one can probably surmise that a
secondary will not be too far in the future if CBOT trades as
well as expected. CBOT handles about 15 percent of all global
listed futures and options, clearly making it one of the world's
leading exchanges for derivatives. Trading volume in 2004 hit 600
million contracts, a 32 percent increase from 2003 (454 million
contracts). Net Income in 2004 was 42 million versus 30.7 million
in 2003. The offering proceeds will be used for general corporate
purposes, including upgrading technology and possible future
acquisitions.
CBOT relies on
the Chicago Mercantile Exchange CME to clear its trades. This
past week has been eventful for CME. Refco RFX one of the Chicago
Mercantile Exchange main customers announced that it will shut
down Refco Capital Management, its nonregulated offshore
securities, and foreign exchange broker, due to liquidity
problems. The CEO who has been charged with Securities fraud
allegedly moved 400 million dollars of bad debts owed to Refco to
a separate company he owned. However, despite these potentially
serious issues, Refco was deemed last Thursday by the Chicago
Mercantile as a member in good standing and continues to meet its
obligations to the exchange. It is strongly expected that current
Refco customers will move their business to other firms on the
exchange. As expected there are numerous class action suits
against Refco. The Chicago Mercantile exchange stated in a
written statement that Refco accounts are protected through
financial safeguards and risk management policies already in
place. My research since the incident coupled with the
fundamentals of CBOT allows me to believe that an
outstanding IPO is imminent. Rating = 5
Our advisory service,
which includes our IPO ratings and in-depth analysis, is
available on your choice of a monthly or annual payment basis. To
receive our advisory service click on